نقضُ الأشاعرةِ نظريةَ الصدورِ الفلسفية
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.66359/71928292Keywords:
Refutation, Ash'arites, theory of emanation, philosophers, theologiansAbstract
This study focuses on the Ash'arite critique of the theory of emanation held by Greek and certain Eastern philosophers. In essence, this theory addresses the manner in which existing things originate from God Almighty, positing that this origination occurs through intermediaries and instruments. The philosophers argued that since God is One in every respect—and "from the One, only one proceeds"—intermediaries are necessary to avoid implying multiplicity within His Essence. Furthermore, they maintained that God brings about this emanation through necessity rather than free choice—meaning His action entails inevitability. Muslims viewed this theory as contrary to the spirit and teachings of Islam, as well as to sound innate nature (*fitra*). Consequently, scholars—particularly the Ash'arites—adopted a decisive stance against the theory, identifying numerous contradictions within it, such as the existence of multiple eternal entities and the equation of the Creator with the created in terms of incapacity and dependency, among other problematic implications.